Douglas N. Walton's Appeal to Pity: Argumentum Ad Misericordiam PDF

By Douglas N. Walton

ISBN-10: 0585062196

ISBN-13: 9780585062198

ISBN-10: 0791434613

ISBN-13: 9780791434611

ISBN-10: 0791434621

ISBN-13: 9780791434628

Entice pity has usually been exploited with striking luck as a misleading tactic of argumentation, rather a lot in order that it has frequently been handled as a fallacy. utilizing a case research technique, the writer examines examples of appeals to pity and compassion in genuine arguments which will classify, examine, and evaluation the categories of arguments utilized in those appeals. one of the circumstances studied are the arguable use of "poster young children" within the Jerry Lewis Telethon for Muscular Dystrophy and the "baby incubators tale" deployed by way of a public relatives enterprise to steer the choice to ship U.S. forces into Kuwait throughout the Gulf struggle. as well as the analyses of those and different case reports, this booklet presents, for the 1st time, specific guidance and precious standards with which to spot, study, and assessment situations of the advert misericordiam argument.

Show description

Read or Download Appeal to Pity: Argumentum Ad Misericordiam PDF

Best methodology books

Awareness systems: advances in theory, methodology and - download pdf or read online

Knowledge platforms might be greatly outlined as these platforms that support humans build and preserve expertise of every others’ actions, context or prestige, whether the contributors will not be co-located. initially meant for helping humans fascinated with a similar actions at diverse destinations, such structures at the moment are used to aid social interactions among any attached members and to help social relationships over sustained classes of time.

Read e-book online Exploratory Social Network Analysis with Pajek (Structural PDF

This is often the 1st textbook on social community research integrating concept, functions, software program for appearing community research (Pajek). Pajek software program and datasets for all examples are freely to be had, so the reader can study community research by means of doing it. additionally, each one bankruptcy bargains case reports for working towards community research.

Read e-book online Appeal to Pity: Argumentum Ad Misericordiam PDF

Entice pity has often been exploited with outstanding luck as a misleading tactic of argumentation, a lot in order that it has usually been handled as a fallacy. utilizing a case research approach, the writer examines examples of appeals to pity and compassion in genuine arguments so one can classify, study, and evaluation the categories of arguments utilized in those appeals.

Approaching Infinity - download pdf or read online

Coming near near Infinity addresses seventeen paradoxes of the countless, such a lot of that have no in most cases authorized ideas. The ebook addresses those paradoxes utilizing a brand new thought of infinity, which involves that an unlimited sequence is uncompletable whilst it calls for whatever to own an unlimited extensive significance.

Additional resources for Appeal to Pity: Argumentum Ad Misericordiam

Sample text

It is a fallacy of relevance, but also a fallacy of "blowing up" the element of pity so that it is out of proportion in the total evidence picture for a case. However, there are some other aspects of the fallacy to be considered as well. Two kinds of cases require additional consideration. Both of these examples, from the same textbook (Kreyche 1970), raise interesting questions about why an appeal to pity should be considered a fallacious argument that seems to go beyond the kind of account given by Weddle and Bonevac.

Two kinds of cases require additional consideration. Both of these examples, from the same textbook (Kreyche 1970), raise interesting questions about why an appeal to pity should be considered a fallacious argument that seems to go beyond the kind of account given by Weddle and Bonevac. One curious type of case used by several of the textbooks 7 could be called the orphan case. The variant below is quoted from Kreyche (1970, p. 25:A young man is on trial for slaying both of his parents. The defense lawyer addresses himself to the jury: "How can you possibly pronounce sentence on this young man?

At any rate, there appears to be some uncertainty in the textbooks on when appeal to pity is appropriate or not as an argument in a legal context. 5. The Student's Plea Case Castell (1935, p. 8: A student who tries to save himself from a failure by reminding his instructor how disastrous such an event would be, is trying an Ad Misericordiam. The unfortunate consequences entailed by any fact do not render it any less a fact. The failure to see this is the essence of the Ad Misericordiam fallacy.

Download PDF sample

Appeal to Pity: Argumentum Ad Misericordiam by Douglas N. Walton


by Paul
4.3

Rated 4.65 of 5 – based on 35 votes